White Hat Financial Service

When investing in mutual funds, one of the biggest psychological challenges investors face is dealing with notional profit or loss. Unlike realized gains or losses, notional values are paper profits or losses that exist only until an investor decides to sell. This often leads to confusion and emotional decision-making.

What is Notional Profit and Loss?

Notional profit or loss refers to the unrealized gains or losses on your mutual fund investments based on the current market value. Until you redeem your units, these are only numbers on paper and do not impact your actual bank balance.

📌 Example:

You invested ₹1,00,000 in a mutual fund.
After a year, the market value of your investment rises to ₹1,20,000.
Your notional profit is ₹20,000.
If the market dips and your investment value falls to ₹90,000, your notional loss is ₹10,000.
The key point: Until you sell, this profit or loss is not real.

The Psychological Dilemma: Should You Act on Notional Profit or Loss?

Many investors struggle with the decision of whether to book profits early or hold onto investments despite temporary market declines. The fear of losing notional profits and the panic of seeing a notional loss often lead to premature exits or holding onto poor investments for too long.

Why Notional Losses Shouldn’t Worry You

📉 Market corrections are temporary – The stock market and mutual funds go through cycles. A dip does not mean a permanent loss unless you sell in panic.

📈 Long-term investing smoothens volatility – Historically, markets have always recovered and rewarded patience.

💡 Example: If you had invested in an equity mutual fund in 2008 (during the market crash), your investment would have significantly grown by this year despite short-term downturns.

Why Notional Profits Shouldn’t Tempt You to Exit Early

🚀 Compounding works best with time – By withdrawing too early, you miss out on exponential wealth growth.

📊 Tax efficiency – Selling mutual fund units before one year in equity funds attracts short-term capital gains tax (STCG), reducing your net returns.

🔄 Market fluctuations are normal – Today’s profit can become higher tomorrow if you stay invested.

When Should You Act on Notional Gains or Losses?

✅ If your financial goal is near, it makes sense to gradually shift funds to safer options like debt funds to protect gains.

✅ If your investment has reached unrealistic valuations, you may book partial profits and rebalance.

✅ If your mutual fund is consistently underperforming, review and consider switching.

Investment Scenarios: How to Handle Notional Profit and Loss

Investment for Goal

If the real financial goal is achieved, you can transfer your investment to safer deposit options like debt funds to secure your capital. This is a crucial step in financial planning because as your goal approaches, market volatility can pose a risk to your accumulated wealth.

For example, if you were saving for your child’s education and had built a corpus through equity mutual funds, moving it to a safer investment like a debt fund ensures that a sudden market downturn does not affect your ability to meet your goal. However, if your goal is not yet achieved and the market is fluctuating, staying invested until the right time is the best course of action.

Investment for Corpus Creation

If you are investing for long-term corpus creation, such as retirement planning or wealth accumulation, it is essential to continue investing regardless of short-term market fluctuations. The goal here is not to time the market but to stay in the market. The longer your money remains invested, the more you benefit from compounding.

Even if your investments show notional losses at times, history suggests that markets tend to recover and grow over extended periods. Investors who panic and exit due to temporary downturns often miss out on subsequent growth opportunities. Instead, focus on systematic investing through SIPs (Systematic Investment Plans) and ensure you have a well-diversified portfolio.

Final Thought: Stay Focused on Long-Term Wealth

Instead of reacting to notional ups and downs, investors should focus on investment objectives and asset allocation. Your financial future depends on staying invested in quality funds, not daily market fluctuations.

“The stock market is a device for transferring money from the impatient to the patient.” – Warren Buffett

What’s Your Take?

Have you ever faced the notional profit or loss dilemma? 🤔 Did you react emotionally or stay invested? 📊 Share your experiences in the comments! 👇